Codersera

4 min to read

YOLO-NAS vs YOLOv12 For Object Detection : Comparision

Object detection is a fundamental task in computer vision, involving the identification and localization of objects within images or videos. Among various object detection algorithms, the You Only Look Once (YOLO) series has gained significant attention due to its real-time performance and high accuracy.

Overview of YOLO Models

YOLO models are single-stage detectors, meaning they handle both object identification and classification in a single pass of the network. This approach allows for faster processing compared to two-stage detectors like Faster R-CNN. Over the years, YOLO models have evolved significantly, with improvements in accuracy, speed, and efficiency.

YOLO-NAS: Architecture and Features

Introduction to YOLO-NAS

YOLO-NAS is a state-of-the-art object detection model developed by Deci, which leverages neural architecture search (NAS) techniques to optimize its architecture. YOLO-NAS is designed to outperform earlier YOLO models such as YOLOv5, v7, and v8 in terms of mean average precision (mAP) and speed.

Key Features of YOLO-NAS

  1. Neural Architecture Search (NAS): YOLO-NAS uses NAS to automatically search for the optimal architecture, which results in better performance compared to manually designed models. This process involves exploring a vast space of possible architectures to find the one that maximizes performance metrics like mAP.
  2. Efficient Architecture: The model is optimized for real-time object detection, ensuring high accuracy while maintaining fast inference speeds. This is crucial for applications requiring immediate object detection, such as autonomous vehicles or surveillance systems.
  3. Scalability: YOLO-NAS is scalable across different hardware platforms, making it suitable for deployment on edge devices as well as cloud infrastructure. This flexibility is essential for various applications where computational resources may vary.
  4. Performance Metrics: YOLO-NAS achieves state-of-the-art performance compared to its predecessors, with significant improvements in mAP. For instance, it outperforms YOLOv6 and YOLOv8 in object detection tasks.

Limitations of YOLO-NAS

While YOLO-NAS offers superior performance, its reliance on NAS techniques can make the training process more complex and computationally intensive. Additionally, the model's performance might be sensitive to the specific NAS algorithm used and the computational resources available during the search process.

YOLOv12: Architecture and Features

Introduction to YOLOv12

YOLOv12 is the latest iteration in the YOLO series, introduced in February 2025. It marks a significant advancement by integrating attention mechanisms into the YOLO framework while maintaining competitive inference speeds. YOLOv12 achieves state-of-the-art object detection accuracy through innovative attention methods and architectural optimizations.

Key Features of YOLOv12

  1. Attention-Centric Architecture: YOLOv12 introduces an attention-centric approach, which enhances object detection accuracy. This includes the use of an Area Attention Mechanism that efficiently processes large receptive fields by dividing feature maps into segments, reducing computational complexity.
  2. Residual Efficient Layer Aggregation Networks (R-ELAN): YOLOv12 leverages R-ELAN to address optimization challenges introduced by attention mechanisms. R-ELAN includes block-level residual connections and scaling techniques to ensure stable training and improved feature aggregation.
  3. Optimized Attention Architecture: The model streamlines the standard attention mechanism using FlashAttention to minimize memory access overhead, removes positional encoding for faster processing, and adjusts the MLP ratio to balance computation between attention and feed-forward layers.
  4. Comprehensive Task Support: YOLOv12 supports a range of computer vision tasks beyond object detection, including instance segmentation, image classification, pose estimation, and oriented object detection.
  5. Performance Metrics: YOLOv12 demonstrates significant accuracy improvements across all model scales compared to prior YOLO models. For example, the lightweight YOLOv12-N achieves 40.6% mAP, while the larger YOLOv12-X reaches 55.2% mAP on the COCO dataset.

Limitations of YOLOv12

A notable limitation of YOLOv12 is its reliance on FlashAttention, which is only supported on modern GPU architectures. This means that older GPUs may not fully benefit from YOLOv12's optimized attention implementation, potentially limiting its deployment on certain hardware platforms.

Comparison of YOLO-NAS and YOLOv12

Architecture Comparison

Feature YOLO-NAS YOLOv12
Architecture Uses NAS to optimize architecture Attention-centric with R-ELAN and Area Attention
Key Innovations Automatic architecture search Integration of attention mechanisms with FlashAttention
Scalability Scalable across hardware platforms Scalable but limited by FlashAttention support

Performance Comparison

Model mAP on COCO Inference Speed (ms) Parameters (M) FLOPs (B)
YOLO-NAS Superior to YOLOv6 & YOLOv8 Real-time performance Not specified Not specified
YOLOv12-N 40.6% 1.64 ms (T4 GPU) 2.6 M 6.5 B
YOLOv12-S 48.0% 2.61 ms (T4 GPU) 9.3 M 21.4 B
YOLOv12-M 52.5% 4.86 ms (T4 GPU) 20.2 M 67.5 B
YOLOv12-L 53.7% 6.77 ms (T4 GPU) 26.4 M 88.9 B
YOLOv12-X 55.2% 11.79 ms (T4 GPU) 59.1 M 199.0 B

Application Comparison

  • YOLO-NAS is particularly suited for applications where the highest accuracy is required, and the computational resources for NAS are available. It is ideal for scenarios where the model needs to be optimized for specific hardware or tasks.
  • YOLOv12 offers a balance between speed and accuracy, making it suitable for real-time applications. Its support for various computer vision tasks beyond object detection expands its applicability across different domains.

Coding Comparison

  • YOLO-NAS:
    • YOLO-NAS does not support training directly. It focuses on inference, validation, and export modes.
    • Its architecture is designed to be quantization-friendly, which is beneficial for deployment on edge devices.
  • YOLOv12:
    • YOLOv12 supports training and inference. The training process involves efficient label assignment techniques.
    • For inference, YOLOv12 leverages FlashAttention, which requires modern GPU architectures (NVIDIA Turing, Ampere, Ada Lovelace, or Hopper families) for optimal speed.

Example code for validation in YOLOv12:PythonCopy

from ultralytics import YOLO

model = YOLO('yolov12n.pt')
model.val(data='coco.yaml', save_json=True)

Conclusion

Both YOLO-NAS and YOLOv12 represent significant advancements in object detection, each with unique strengths. YOLO-NAS excels through its use of NAS to achieve superior performance, while YOLOv12 integrates attention mechanisms to enhance accuracy while maintaining real-time speeds.

The choice between these models depends on specific application requirements, such as the need for the highest accuracy versus the importance of real-time processing.

References

  1. Run DeepSeek Janus-Pro 7B on Mac: A Comprehensive Guide Using ComfyUI
  2. Run DeepSeek Janus-Pro 7B on Mac: Step-by-Step Guide
  3. Run Microsoft OmniParser V2 on Ubuntu : Step by Step Installation Guide
  4. Run SmolVLM2 2.2B on macOS: Installation Guide

Need expert guidance? Connect with a top Codersera professional today!

;